Skip to main content
placeholder image

Reply to the comment by Dougherty, A.J. on ¿Relative sea-level records preserved in Holocene beach-ridge strandplains ¿ An example from tropical northeastern Australia¿ by Brooke, B.P., Huang, Z., Nicholas, W.A., Oliver, T.S.N., Tamura, T., Woodroffe, C.D., Nichol, S.L.

Journal Article


Abstract


  • The approach and results of our 2019 paper (Brooke et al., 2019) have been criticised by Dougherty (2022). We examined the sensitivity of a tropical, coarse sand strandplain to changes in relative sea level as expressed through beach-ridge morphology and the elevation of beach berms preserved in the succession of cyclone-generated beach ridges at Cowley Beach, Queensland, Australia. Rather than presenting a new sea-level curve for this region as suggested by Dougherty, our 2019 study of the Cowley Beach strandplain revealed that when compared with the modelled Holocene relative sea-level record and sea-level indicator data for north-eastern Queensland, the strandplain morphology and stratigraphy provide a first-order representation of sea-level position. Importantly, Dougherty (2022) has overlooked the processes involved in the formation of beach ridges at this site and the spatial coverage of our analysis of the strandplain morphology. Both these factors are fundamental to the approach and conclusions of our 2019 paper. We reiterate here that the Cowley Beach strandplain morphology and succession of beach-berm deposits have elevation patterns that match well the broad trend in the regional relative sea-level model for the past 7 ka. We highlight those key beach-ridge formative processes and data limitations neglected in the Dougherty Comment. Finally, we note the challenges and opportunities for further research into the sedimentary records preserved in this distinctive type of tropical strandplain.

Publication Date


  • 2022

Citation


  • Brooke, B. P., Huang, Z., Nicholas, W. A., Oliver, T. S. N., Tamura, T., Woodroffe, C. D., & Nichol, S. L. (2022). Reply to the comment by Dougherty, A.J. on ¿Relative sea-level records preserved in Holocene beach-ridge strandplains ¿ An example from tropical northeastern Australia¿ by Brooke, B.P., Huang, Z., Nicholas, W.A., Oliver, T.S.N., Tamura, T., Woodroffe, C.D., Nichol, S.L.. Marine Geology, 447. doi:10.1016/j.margeo.2022.106768

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85127893354

Web Of Science Accession Number


Volume


  • 447

Abstract


  • The approach and results of our 2019 paper (Brooke et al., 2019) have been criticised by Dougherty (2022). We examined the sensitivity of a tropical, coarse sand strandplain to changes in relative sea level as expressed through beach-ridge morphology and the elevation of beach berms preserved in the succession of cyclone-generated beach ridges at Cowley Beach, Queensland, Australia. Rather than presenting a new sea-level curve for this region as suggested by Dougherty, our 2019 study of the Cowley Beach strandplain revealed that when compared with the modelled Holocene relative sea-level record and sea-level indicator data for north-eastern Queensland, the strandplain morphology and stratigraphy provide a first-order representation of sea-level position. Importantly, Dougherty (2022) has overlooked the processes involved in the formation of beach ridges at this site and the spatial coverage of our analysis of the strandplain morphology. Both these factors are fundamental to the approach and conclusions of our 2019 paper. We reiterate here that the Cowley Beach strandplain morphology and succession of beach-berm deposits have elevation patterns that match well the broad trend in the regional relative sea-level model for the past 7 ka. We highlight those key beach-ridge formative processes and data limitations neglected in the Dougherty Comment. Finally, we note the challenges and opportunities for further research into the sedimentary records preserved in this distinctive type of tropical strandplain.

Publication Date


  • 2022

Citation


  • Brooke, B. P., Huang, Z., Nicholas, W. A., Oliver, T. S. N., Tamura, T., Woodroffe, C. D., & Nichol, S. L. (2022). Reply to the comment by Dougherty, A.J. on ¿Relative sea-level records preserved in Holocene beach-ridge strandplains ¿ An example from tropical northeastern Australia¿ by Brooke, B.P., Huang, Z., Nicholas, W.A., Oliver, T.S.N., Tamura, T., Woodroffe, C.D., Nichol, S.L.. Marine Geology, 447. doi:10.1016/j.margeo.2022.106768

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85127893354

Web Of Science Accession Number


Volume


  • 447