Skip to main content
placeholder image

Is muscular strength a critical physical attribute for the apprehension of a simulated non-compliant suspect?

Journal Article


Abstract


  • This investigation determined the influence of technique and experience on arm retraction force required to apprehend a non-compliant suspect. Phase-One: Nine experienced RAAF military-police completed four apprehension simulations, peak arm retraction force was measured; i) Control(CON), ii) Pressure-Point(PP), iii) Targeted-Striking(TS) and iv) 2-Person(2Per) techniques. Phase-Two: Experienced (EXP, n = 8) or Inexperienced (INEXP, n = 22) military-police completed CON, PP and Pressure-Point + Coaching(PP + C). Strength was assessed in INEXP. EXP produced more force (178.7 N ± 25.9) than INEXP during CON, but no participant successfully apprehended the suspect. All EXP were successful with PP, arm retraction force 357 N (CI: 233.7,480.2) was lower compared to CON, but no difference was observed between PP and CON for INEXP. PP + C, 82% of INEXP were successful, force declined 138.2 N (CI: 67.8,208.5) compared to CON. All EXP required PP for successful apprehension. INEXP required PP + C for apprehension success. Muscular strength had a limited relationship with arm retraction force. Practitioner summary: For law enforcement personnel, apprehension of a suspect is a critical and physically demanding task, where success is associated with muscular strength and technique. We observed success in the apprehension of a simulated suspect by military law enforcement personnel was primarily determined by participant skill and experience and not muscular strength.

Publication Date


  • 2021

Citation


  • Delbridge, K., Caldwell, J., Middleton, K., Drain, J. R., Hayes, A., Burdon, C. A., & Groeller, H. (2021). Is muscular strength a critical physical attribute for the apprehension of a simulated non-compliant suspect?. Ergonomics, 64(9), 1183-1190. doi:10.1080/00140139.2021.1918769

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85105313448

Start Page


  • 1183

End Page


  • 1190

Volume


  • 64

Issue


  • 9

Abstract


  • This investigation determined the influence of technique and experience on arm retraction force required to apprehend a non-compliant suspect. Phase-One: Nine experienced RAAF military-police completed four apprehension simulations, peak arm retraction force was measured; i) Control(CON), ii) Pressure-Point(PP), iii) Targeted-Striking(TS) and iv) 2-Person(2Per) techniques. Phase-Two: Experienced (EXP, n = 8) or Inexperienced (INEXP, n = 22) military-police completed CON, PP and Pressure-Point + Coaching(PP + C). Strength was assessed in INEXP. EXP produced more force (178.7 N ± 25.9) than INEXP during CON, but no participant successfully apprehended the suspect. All EXP were successful with PP, arm retraction force 357 N (CI: 233.7,480.2) was lower compared to CON, but no difference was observed between PP and CON for INEXP. PP + C, 82% of INEXP were successful, force declined 138.2 N (CI: 67.8,208.5) compared to CON. All EXP required PP for successful apprehension. INEXP required PP + C for apprehension success. Muscular strength had a limited relationship with arm retraction force. Practitioner summary: For law enforcement personnel, apprehension of a suspect is a critical and physically demanding task, where success is associated with muscular strength and technique. We observed success in the apprehension of a simulated suspect by military law enforcement personnel was primarily determined by participant skill and experience and not muscular strength.

Publication Date


  • 2021

Citation


  • Delbridge, K., Caldwell, J., Middleton, K., Drain, J. R., Hayes, A., Burdon, C. A., & Groeller, H. (2021). Is muscular strength a critical physical attribute for the apprehension of a simulated non-compliant suspect?. Ergonomics, 64(9), 1183-1190. doi:10.1080/00140139.2021.1918769

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85105313448

Start Page


  • 1183

End Page


  • 1190

Volume


  • 64

Issue


  • 9