Skip to main content
placeholder image

More philosophical work needed in One Health on ethical frameworks and theory

Journal Article


Abstract


  • We thank Zohar Lederman and Benjamin Capps for engaging with our paper on One Health (OH) and ethical frameworks, however we want to take issue with them on three points. First, they appear to misunderstand the distinction we appeal to between ethical theory and ethical frameworks, and so misinterpret what we are trying to achieve in our paper. Second, in spite of what they seem to imply, we agree that an OH approach can obscure differences in values, and that to progress the field there needs to be recognition of competing values and their implications for OH. Finally, we are puzzled by their interest in pursuing a deliberative process, as this seems at odds with other positions they take in their paper, and also opens up many questions that need to be addressed.

Publication Date


  • 2020

Publisher


Citation


  • Johnson, J., & Degeling, C. (2020). More philosophical work needed in One Health on ethical frameworks and theory. Journal of Medical Ethics, 46(10), 705-706. doi:10.1136/medethics-2020-106243

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85091593830

Start Page


  • 705

End Page


  • 706

Volume


  • 46

Issue


  • 10

Abstract


  • We thank Zohar Lederman and Benjamin Capps for engaging with our paper on One Health (OH) and ethical frameworks, however we want to take issue with them on three points. First, they appear to misunderstand the distinction we appeal to between ethical theory and ethical frameworks, and so misinterpret what we are trying to achieve in our paper. Second, in spite of what they seem to imply, we agree that an OH approach can obscure differences in values, and that to progress the field there needs to be recognition of competing values and their implications for OH. Finally, we are puzzled by their interest in pursuing a deliberative process, as this seems at odds with other positions they take in their paper, and also opens up many questions that need to be addressed.

Publication Date


  • 2020

Publisher


Citation


  • Johnson, J., & Degeling, C. (2020). More philosophical work needed in One Health on ethical frameworks and theory. Journal of Medical Ethics, 46(10), 705-706. doi:10.1136/medethics-2020-106243

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85091593830

Start Page


  • 705

End Page


  • 706

Volume


  • 46

Issue


  • 10