placeholder image

Waypoints on a journey of discovery: mental models in human environment interactions

Journal Article


Download full-text (Open Access)

Abstract


  • Although the broad concept of mental models is gaining currency as a way to explore the link between how people

    think and interact with their world, this concept is limited by a theoretical and practical understanding of how it can be applied

    in the study of human-environment relationships. Tools and processes are needed to be able to elicit and analyze mental models.

    Because mental models are not directly observable, it is also important to understand how the application of any tools and

    processes affects what is measured. Equally important are the needs to be clear on the intent of the elicitation and to design the

    methods and choose the settings accordingly. Through this special edition, we explore how mental models are elicited using

    two approaches applied in two case-study regions. We analyze two approaches used in the Crocodile River catchment of South

    Africa: a graphically based approach, i.e., actors, resources, dynamics, and interactions (ARDI); and an interview- or text-based

    approach, i.e., consensus analysis (CA). A further experiment in the Rhone Delta (Camargue), France, enabled us to test a crossover

    between these two methods using ARDI methodology to collect data and CA to analyse it. Here, we compare and explore

    the limitations and challenges in applying these two methods in context and conclude that they have much to offer when used

    singly or in combination. We first develop a conceptual framework as a synthesis of key social and cognitive psychology

    literature. We then use this framework to guide the enquiry into the key lessons emerging from the comparative application of

    these approaches to eliciting mental models in the two case regions. We identify key gaps in our knowledge and suggest important

    research questions that remain to be addressed.

Authors


  •   Lynam, Timothy (external author)
  •   Mathevet, Raphael (external author)
  •   Etienne, Michel (external author)
  •   Stone-Jovicich, Samantha (external author)
  •   Leitch, Anne (external author)
  •   Jones, Nathalie (external author)
  •   Ross, Helen (external author)
  •   Du Toit, Derick (external author)
  •   Pollard, Sharon (external author)
  •   Biggs, Harry (external author)
  •   Perez, Pascal

Publication Date


  • 2012

Citation


  • Lynam, T., Mathevet, R., Etienne, M., Stone-Jovicich, S., Leitch, A., Jones, N., Ross, H., Du Toit, D., Pollard, S., Biggs, H. & Perez, P. (2012). Waypoints on a journey of discovery: mental models in human environment interactions. Ecology and Society: a journal of integrative science for resilience and sustainability, 17 (3), 23-33.

Ro Full-text Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1083&context=smartpapers

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/smartpapers/56

Number Of Pages


  • 10

Start Page


  • 23

End Page


  • 33

Volume


  • 17

Issue


  • 3

Abstract


  • Although the broad concept of mental models is gaining currency as a way to explore the link between how people

    think and interact with their world, this concept is limited by a theoretical and practical understanding of how it can be applied

    in the study of human-environment relationships. Tools and processes are needed to be able to elicit and analyze mental models.

    Because mental models are not directly observable, it is also important to understand how the application of any tools and

    processes affects what is measured. Equally important are the needs to be clear on the intent of the elicitation and to design the

    methods and choose the settings accordingly. Through this special edition, we explore how mental models are elicited using

    two approaches applied in two case-study regions. We analyze two approaches used in the Crocodile River catchment of South

    Africa: a graphically based approach, i.e., actors, resources, dynamics, and interactions (ARDI); and an interview- or text-based

    approach, i.e., consensus analysis (CA). A further experiment in the Rhone Delta (Camargue), France, enabled us to test a crossover

    between these two methods using ARDI methodology to collect data and CA to analyse it. Here, we compare and explore

    the limitations and challenges in applying these two methods in context and conclude that they have much to offer when used

    singly or in combination. We first develop a conceptual framework as a synthesis of key social and cognitive psychology

    literature. We then use this framework to guide the enquiry into the key lessons emerging from the comparative application of

    these approaches to eliciting mental models in the two case regions. We identify key gaps in our knowledge and suggest important

    research questions that remain to be addressed.

Authors


  •   Lynam, Timothy (external author)
  •   Mathevet, Raphael (external author)
  •   Etienne, Michel (external author)
  •   Stone-Jovicich, Samantha (external author)
  •   Leitch, Anne (external author)
  •   Jones, Nathalie (external author)
  •   Ross, Helen (external author)
  •   Du Toit, Derick (external author)
  •   Pollard, Sharon (external author)
  •   Biggs, Harry (external author)
  •   Perez, Pascal

Publication Date


  • 2012

Citation


  • Lynam, T., Mathevet, R., Etienne, M., Stone-Jovicich, S., Leitch, A., Jones, N., Ross, H., Du Toit, D., Pollard, S., Biggs, H. & Perez, P. (2012). Waypoints on a journey of discovery: mental models in human environment interactions. Ecology and Society: a journal of integrative science for resilience and sustainability, 17 (3), 23-33.

Ro Full-text Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1083&context=smartpapers

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/smartpapers/56

Number Of Pages


  • 10

Start Page


  • 23

End Page


  • 33

Volume


  • 17

Issue


  • 3