Skip to main content
placeholder image

Management's critical turn: a critique of Adler's "paleo-marxism"

Journal Article


Abstract


  • Originated by Paul Adler, paleo-Marxism represents the fullest engagement with Marx's work by a management scholar in the American milieu. As the pinnacle of Marxist thinking within Critical Management Studies, paleo-Marxism merits critical attention. By focusing on technological change, Adler aims to overcome contemporary poststructuralist labor process theory's subjectivism. When subjected to a fine-grained analysis, however, paleo-Marxism is revealed to be equally deficient. Adler compounds the labor process theorists' neglect of Marx's discoveries about how capital is valorized; he prioritizes the subjective matter of recognition at the expense of redistribution; and he fails to explain adequately the crisis potential of technical progress. Only a wholly new Marxist version of Critical Management Studies, one with a “crisis sites” model at its core, can surmount paleo-Marxism's inherent weaknesses.

Publication Date


  • 2011

Citation


  • Reveley, J. (2011). Management''s critical turn: a critique of Adler''s "paleo-marxism". Science and Society: a journal of marxist thought and analysis, 75 (3), 325-347.

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-79959616411

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/commpapers/1545

Has Global Citation Frequency


Number Of Pages


  • 22

Start Page


  • 325

End Page


  • 347

Volume


  • 75

Issue


  • 3

Abstract


  • Originated by Paul Adler, paleo-Marxism represents the fullest engagement with Marx's work by a management scholar in the American milieu. As the pinnacle of Marxist thinking within Critical Management Studies, paleo-Marxism merits critical attention. By focusing on technological change, Adler aims to overcome contemporary poststructuralist labor process theory's subjectivism. When subjected to a fine-grained analysis, however, paleo-Marxism is revealed to be equally deficient. Adler compounds the labor process theorists' neglect of Marx's discoveries about how capital is valorized; he prioritizes the subjective matter of recognition at the expense of redistribution; and he fails to explain adequately the crisis potential of technical progress. Only a wholly new Marxist version of Critical Management Studies, one with a “crisis sites” model at its core, can surmount paleo-Marxism's inherent weaknesses.

Publication Date


  • 2011

Citation


  • Reveley, J. (2011). Management''s critical turn: a critique of Adler''s "paleo-marxism". Science and Society: a journal of marxist thought and analysis, 75 (3), 325-347.

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-79959616411

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/commpapers/1545

Has Global Citation Frequency


Number Of Pages


  • 22

Start Page


  • 325

End Page


  • 347

Volume


  • 75

Issue


  • 3