Skip to main content

Ecological inference techniques: an empirical evaluation using data describing gender and voter turnout at New Zealand elections, 1893-1919

Journal Article


Abstract


  • Summary. The difference, if any, between men's and women's voting patterns is of particular interest to historians of gender and politics. For elections that were held before the introduction of opinion surveying in the 1940s, little data are available with which to estimate such differences. We apply six methods for ecological inference to estimate men's and women's voting rates in New Zealand (NZ), 1893–1919. NZ is an interesting case-study, since it was the first self-governing country where women could vote. Furthermore, NZ officials recorded the voting rates of men and women at elections, making it possible to compare estimates produced by methods for ecological inference with known true values, thus testing the efficacy of different methods for ecological inference for this data set. We find that the most popular methods for ecological inference, namely Goodman's ecological regression and King's parametric method, give poor estimates, as does the much debated neighbourhood method. However, King's non-parametric method, Chambers and Steel's semiparametric method and the Steel, Beh and Chambers homogeneous approach all gave good estimates that were close to the known values, with the homogeneous approach performing best overall. The success of these methods in this example suggests that ecological inference may be a viable option when investigating gender and voting. Moreover, researchers using ecological inference in other fields may do well to consider a range of statistical methods. This work is a significant NZ contribution to historical politics and the first quantitative contribution, in the area of NZ gender and politics

Authors


  •   Hudson, Irene L. (external author)
  •   Moore, Linda (external author)
  •   Beh, Eric (external author)
  •   Steel, David G

Publication Date


  • 2010

Citation


  • Hudson, I. L., Moore, L., Beh, E. & Steel, D. G. (2010). Ecological inference techniques: an empirical evaluation using data describing gender and voter turnout at New Zealand elections, 1893-1919. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 173 (Part 1), 185-213.

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-72249105504

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/infopapers/3335

Number Of Pages


  • 28

Start Page


  • 185

End Page


  • 213

Volume


  • 173

Issue


  • Part 1

Place Of Publication


  • http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/fulltext/122582013/PDFSTART

Abstract


  • Summary. The difference, if any, between men's and women's voting patterns is of particular interest to historians of gender and politics. For elections that were held before the introduction of opinion surveying in the 1940s, little data are available with which to estimate such differences. We apply six methods for ecological inference to estimate men's and women's voting rates in New Zealand (NZ), 1893–1919. NZ is an interesting case-study, since it was the first self-governing country where women could vote. Furthermore, NZ officials recorded the voting rates of men and women at elections, making it possible to compare estimates produced by methods for ecological inference with known true values, thus testing the efficacy of different methods for ecological inference for this data set. We find that the most popular methods for ecological inference, namely Goodman's ecological regression and King's parametric method, give poor estimates, as does the much debated neighbourhood method. However, King's non-parametric method, Chambers and Steel's semiparametric method and the Steel, Beh and Chambers homogeneous approach all gave good estimates that were close to the known values, with the homogeneous approach performing best overall. The success of these methods in this example suggests that ecological inference may be a viable option when investigating gender and voting. Moreover, researchers using ecological inference in other fields may do well to consider a range of statistical methods. This work is a significant NZ contribution to historical politics and the first quantitative contribution, in the area of NZ gender and politics

Authors


  •   Hudson, Irene L. (external author)
  •   Moore, Linda (external author)
  •   Beh, Eric (external author)
  •   Steel, David G

Publication Date


  • 2010

Citation


  • Hudson, I. L., Moore, L., Beh, E. & Steel, D. G. (2010). Ecological inference techniques: an empirical evaluation using data describing gender and voter turnout at New Zealand elections, 1893-1919. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A: Statistics in Society, 173 (Part 1), 185-213.

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-72249105504

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/infopapers/3335

Number Of Pages


  • 28

Start Page


  • 185

End Page


  • 213

Volume


  • 173

Issue


  • Part 1

Place Of Publication


  • http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/fulltext/122582013/PDFSTART