Skip to main content
placeholder image

Leeching Bataille: peer-to-peer Potlatch and the Acephalic Response

Conference Paper


Download full-text (Open Access)

Abstract


  • As a model of resource distribution, social interaction, and collective content management, peer-to-peer technologies (p2p) offer unprecedented insights into the contemporary organisation of information and the limitations of the legal, cultural, and institutional frameworks under which this organisation is currently managed. The utopian ideal of p2p music distribution, for instance, imagines the largest collectively and voluntarily maintained, decentralised (and thus easily accessible), and free archive of recorded sound in human history. P2p is often associated with open source, hacker, creative commons, and general collaborative approaches to content production and distribution, and with the dissemination of a number of niche genres which would otherwise have remained largely unknown (or, indeed, might never have developed at all). Taken in its broader environment, p2p has also arguably been instrumental to the emergence of netlabels as distributive and cultural phenomena. It cannot be doubted that the impact of p2p on the established music industry, the legal framework in which it operates, and the practices of artists, fans and consumers has been profound, and it can also be argued that p2p in some ways contributed to the ground for the user-generated content and participatory nature of 'Web 2.0'.

    For some time, it has been popular to conceptualise p2p with frameworks drawn from anthropological economics, which bypass the normative catallactic assumptions about market behaviour associated with neoclassical economism (the 'rational', means/end calculating, self-interested market agent and so on). In particular, the array of concepts around the economy of the gift, derived variously from Mauss, Malinowski and others, have been deployed to account for the ostensibly 'irrational' altruism and reciprocity which seem to characterise so much p2p activity. However, it may be that this use of theories of the gift tend to exaggerate and romanticise the benevolence of p2p behaviour, and unwittingly enforce the utopian idealism associated with p2p as a social practice with political implications, and as an alternative model for the equitable distribution of cultural goods.

Publication Date


  • 2009

Citation


  • Whelan, A. M. (2009). Leeching Bataille: peer-to-peer Potlatch and the Acephalic Response. In J. Prada (Eds.), Inclusiva-net Meeting: P2P Networks and Processes (pp. 1-15). Madrid: Medialab Prado.

Ro Full-text Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2828&context=artspapers

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/artspapers/1782

Start Page


  • 1

End Page


  • 15

Place Of Publication


  • http://medialab-prado.es/article/leeching_bataille_peer-to-peer_potlatch_and_the_acephalic_response

Abstract


  • As a model of resource distribution, social interaction, and collective content management, peer-to-peer technologies (p2p) offer unprecedented insights into the contemporary organisation of information and the limitations of the legal, cultural, and institutional frameworks under which this organisation is currently managed. The utopian ideal of p2p music distribution, for instance, imagines the largest collectively and voluntarily maintained, decentralised (and thus easily accessible), and free archive of recorded sound in human history. P2p is often associated with open source, hacker, creative commons, and general collaborative approaches to content production and distribution, and with the dissemination of a number of niche genres which would otherwise have remained largely unknown (or, indeed, might never have developed at all). Taken in its broader environment, p2p has also arguably been instrumental to the emergence of netlabels as distributive and cultural phenomena. It cannot be doubted that the impact of p2p on the established music industry, the legal framework in which it operates, and the practices of artists, fans and consumers has been profound, and it can also be argued that p2p in some ways contributed to the ground for the user-generated content and participatory nature of 'Web 2.0'.

    For some time, it has been popular to conceptualise p2p with frameworks drawn from anthropological economics, which bypass the normative catallactic assumptions about market behaviour associated with neoclassical economism (the 'rational', means/end calculating, self-interested market agent and so on). In particular, the array of concepts around the economy of the gift, derived variously from Mauss, Malinowski and others, have been deployed to account for the ostensibly 'irrational' altruism and reciprocity which seem to characterise so much p2p activity. However, it may be that this use of theories of the gift tend to exaggerate and romanticise the benevolence of p2p behaviour, and unwittingly enforce the utopian idealism associated with p2p as a social practice with political implications, and as an alternative model for the equitable distribution of cultural goods.

Publication Date


  • 2009

Citation


  • Whelan, A. M. (2009). Leeching Bataille: peer-to-peer Potlatch and the Acephalic Response. In J. Prada (Eds.), Inclusiva-net Meeting: P2P Networks and Processes (pp. 1-15). Madrid: Medialab Prado.

Ro Full-text Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2828&context=artspapers

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/artspapers/1782

Start Page


  • 1

End Page


  • 15

Place Of Publication


  • http://medialab-prado.es/article/leeching_bataille_peer-to-peer_potlatch_and_the_acephalic_response