Skip to main content
placeholder image

How to determine the boundaries of the mind: a Markov blanket proposal

Journal Article


Abstract


  • We develop a truism of commonsense psychology that perception and action constitute the boundaries of the mind. We do so however not on the basis of commonsense psychology, but by using the notion of a Markov blanket originally employed to describe the topological properties of causal networks. We employ the Markov blanket formalism to propose precise criteria for demarcating the boundaries of the mind that unlike other rival candidates for “marks of the cognitive” avoids begging the question in the extended mind debate. Our criteria imply that the boundary of the mind is nested and multiscale sometimes extending beyond the individual agent to incorporate items located in the environment. Chalmers has used commonsense psychology to develop what he sees as the most serious challenge to the view that minds sometimes extend into the world. He has argued that perception and action should be thought of as interfaces that separate minds from their surrounding environment. In a series of recent papers Hohwy has defended a similar claim using the Markov blanket formalism. We use the Markov blanket formalism to show how both of their objections to the extended mind fail.

Publication Date


  • 2019

Citation


  • Kirchhoff, M. D. & Kiverstein, J. (2019). How to determine the boundaries of the mind: a Markov blanket proposal. Synthese: an international journal for epistemology, methodology and philosophy of science, Online First 1-20.

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85071264045

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/lhapapers/3992

Number Of Pages


  • 19

Start Page


  • 1

End Page


  • 20

Volume


  • Online First

Place Of Publication


  • Netherlands

Abstract


  • We develop a truism of commonsense psychology that perception and action constitute the boundaries of the mind. We do so however not on the basis of commonsense psychology, but by using the notion of a Markov blanket originally employed to describe the topological properties of causal networks. We employ the Markov blanket formalism to propose precise criteria for demarcating the boundaries of the mind that unlike other rival candidates for “marks of the cognitive” avoids begging the question in the extended mind debate. Our criteria imply that the boundary of the mind is nested and multiscale sometimes extending beyond the individual agent to incorporate items located in the environment. Chalmers has used commonsense psychology to develop what he sees as the most serious challenge to the view that minds sometimes extend into the world. He has argued that perception and action should be thought of as interfaces that separate minds from their surrounding environment. In a series of recent papers Hohwy has defended a similar claim using the Markov blanket formalism. We use the Markov blanket formalism to show how both of their objections to the extended mind fail.

Publication Date


  • 2019

Citation


  • Kirchhoff, M. D. & Kiverstein, J. (2019). How to determine the boundaries of the mind: a Markov blanket proposal. Synthese: an international journal for epistemology, methodology and philosophy of science, Online First 1-20.

Scopus Eid


  • 2-s2.0-85071264045

Ro Metadata Url


  • http://ro.uow.edu.au/lhapapers/3992

Number Of Pages


  • 19

Start Page


  • 1

End Page


  • 20

Volume


  • Online First

Place Of Publication


  • Netherlands